Beyond the cane: Rethinking discipline in schools

Beyond the cane: Rethinking discipline in schools

By Mbah-Nwanegbo Ronnie, Educator at Lagooz School

Discipline is one of the most important pillars of education.  It helps students develop self-control, obedience, and respect for authority.

In  many  schools   especially  in the past,  flogging or corporal punishment was the most  common  method  of  correcting  wrong  behaviour.

 Teachers  often  believed  that  the cane was  the  fastest  way  to  ensure  obedience,  sometimes  even  backing  this  belief  with  the  popular saying, “Spare the rod and spoil the child.” However,  in  recent  years,  many  educators  and  child  psychologists  have  strongly  criticised  flogging  because  it  can  create  fear,  resentment,  and  even  physical  or emotional harm.

This shift has led to an important question: Without flogging, how can students be disciplined effectively?

1. Counselling and moral instruction

Counselling is one of the most effective and humane forms of discipline. When a student misbehaves, a teacher or school counsellor can hold a private conversation with the child to understand the reason behind the behaviour and offer moral guidance. This  approach  helps  students  reflect  on  their  actions,  learn  responsibility,  and  grow  in character. It also fosters mutual respect and strengthens the relationship between teachers and students.

Corrective academic tasks

Instead of physical punishment, schools can assign constructive academic tasks. For example, a student who refuses to do homework could be asked to write an essay on “The Importance of Responsibility” or to complete additional exercises.  Such measures discourage laziness, promote accountability, and reinforce learning while instilling discipline.

Community or school service

Assigning community or school service is another positive strategy. Offending students can sweep  classrooms,  water  school  gardens,  arrange  library  books,  or  clean  the  assembly ground. These tasks teach humility, teamwork, and respect for the dignity of labour. They also help students appreciate the importance of maintaining a clean and orderly environment.

Withdrawal of privileges

Withholding privileges can be an effective corrective measure. Students who break school rules may temporarily lose access to games, parties, or excursions. When  learners  realise  that  good  behaviour  earns  rewards  while  misconduct  removes  them, they become more motivated to act responsibly.

Apologies and restorative actions

Encouraging students to apologise — verbally or in writing — promotes accountability and emotional maturity.  A sincere apology fosters honesty, courage, and empathy while helping restore peace within the school community.

 Conclusion

Flogging is not the only path to discipline. Through counselling, corrective work, community service,  withdrawal  of  privileges,  and  restorative  actions,  teachers  can  shape  behaviour  in ways that are both educational and humane. True discipline should build character, not fear.  It should teach students to choose right conduct; not  because  they  dread  punishment,  but  because  they  understand  the  value  of good behaviour.

By Teen Trust News

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts